Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Neil Wilson's avatar

Much as I agree with your assessment, you have to be a little careful with the definitions. Liabilities and Equity are not as you have described. There is no 'owners equity'. There is just 'equity' under the accounting standards.

Liability has a specific meaning under International Standards: "a present obligation of the entity arising from past events, the settlement of which is expected to result in an outflow from the entity of resources embodying economic benefits."

The liability becomes contingent (and off balance sheet) if the obligation becomes a 'possible obligation' rather than a present one.

Equity is then 'not a liability' on the credit side (and includes contingent liabilities). Essentially the balancing item on the accounts.

An entity is required to classify its financial instruments according to the rules laid down in IAS 32: "The issuer of a financial instrument shall classify the instrument, or its component parts, on initial recognition as a financial liability, a financial asset or an equity instrument in accordance with the substance of the contractual arrangement and the definitions of a financial liability, a financial asset and an equity instrument."

Because of the explosion of financial contracts, where they go in the liability/equity divide is a matter of fierce debate. For example 16C of the standard states

"Some financial instruments include a contractual obligation for the issuing entity to deliver to another entity a pro rata share of its net assets only on liquidation. The obligation arises because liquidation either is certain to occur and outside the control of the entity (for example, a limited life entity) or is uncertain to occur but is at the option of the instrument holder. As an exception to the definition of a financial liability, an instrument that includes such an obligation is classified as an equity instrument if it has all the following features:"

And when you read the features, bank notes arguably fall into that category. Then you move onto 16D and there is a saving condition that is probably the 'get out of jail free' card that keeps bank notes as liabilities. ("If the entity cannot determine that this condition is met, it shall not classify the instrument as an equity instrument.")

Ultimately the government sector is akin to a singularity in physics. The standard rules start to break down. Almost certainly the best approach is to abandon 'assets' and 'liabilities' and stick to good old credits and debits. Being 'in credit' and 'in debt' is good enough to cover all the bases without endless arguments about largely meaningless boxes.

Expand full comment
eg's avatar

I will have to re-read this and think about it again. For now I think of bank notes as a government liability because they are tax credits.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts